Monday, April 28, 2014

Selling artifacts of genocide? (h/t @anishinaboy)

Former APTN reporter and Ojibway factotum Tim Fontaine Tweeted this item from a high-end auction brochure from Waddington's in Toronto.

The item description reads:

NORTHERN PLAINS INDIAN
CHILD’S TUNIC, EARLY 19TH
CENTURY
fringed and with beaded collar, showing
signs of central bullet trauma, cased, 23”
x 31” — 58.4 x 78.7 cm

That's right. It's a child's shirt. From the time when Americans were pushing westward through the Great Plains of the continent, slaughtering bison — and often, human beings —in the name of Manifest Destiny.

This artifact is one among dozens that belonged to anthropological collector Billy Jamieson, who died a few years ago.  The auction house says it was purchased originally from Tom Hampton in Santa Fe, New Mexico. How Mr. Hampton came upon it is not mentioned. But it is valued at $2-3,000.

Mr. Fontaine updates that the post is no longer on the Waddington's site. (He complained via e-mail.) 




So, why is this a problem? After all, we have no idea who shot this child. It could have been anyone, even another Native American.

No matter what the original provenance of the tunic, it is evidence of a historical murder of a child, within the context of what many consider an era of attempted genocide of Native Americans by European settlers.

It's not a historical curiosity. It is a symbol of horror. And I hope it will be repatriated soon to the unfortunate child's people for proper respect, rather than becoming a conversation piece in another rich guy's parlour.

The auction is tomorrow. Waddington's contact info is here.

Update:




The other two items removed were "FOUR PAIRS OF NORTHEAST WOODLANDS INDIAN
MOCCASINS, 19TH/EARLY 20TH CENTURY" and "THREE PAIRS NORTH AMERICAN NATIVE INDIAN MOCCASINS, 19TH AND 20TH CENTURIES"

You can still see the original catalogue here.

UPDATE: The issue has been picked up by mainstream media.

No comments:

Post a Comment